When it comes to choosing a compact luxury SUV in Quebec, the duel between the 2025 Acura RDX and the 2025 Audi Q5 naturally stands out. These two models compete in elegance, technology, and performance — but which one is better suited to our winters and to life in Montreal?
In a city like Montreal, where road conditions, harsh winters, and luxury/technology criteria play a key role in choosing a vehicle, this comparison is practical and relevant. Moreover, for customers in the province of Quebec, specific factors (climate, winters, service, warranties) carry even more weight. We will therefore look not only at the numbers, but also at the aspects that matter in everyday use in the Montreal area and elsewhere in Quebec.
Overview and Market Positioning
The 2025 Acura RDX — What It Offers
The 2025 Acura RDX is powered by a 2.0L turbocharged four-cylinder engine delivering about 272 horsepower and 280 lb-ft of torque. This engine is paired with a 10-speed automatic transmission and Acura’s standard SH-AWD (Super Handling All-Wheel Drive) system. The SH-AWD system provides torque vectoring, which improves both handling and cornering behavior.
In terms of fuel economy, the combined rating is estimated at around 23 mpg (21 mpg city / 27 mpg highway) in the United States, which is reasonable for the segment. The RDX can tow up to 1,500 lb (680 kg), depending on the version.
The RDX interior is designed to blend luxury with practicality: quality materials, refined finishes, and thoughtful ergonomics. Tech features include a central display, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration, as well as a suite of driver-assistance systems (collision detection, assistance, warnings).
The 2025 Audi Q5 — What It Brings
The 2025 Audi Q5 in its new generation adopts a 2.0L turbo engine (with a mild-hybrid system) producing 268 horsepower and about 295 lb-ft of torque according to some sources. It comes with a 7-speed S tronic dual-clutch transmission and standard quattro all-wheel drive. Audi claims a 0–60 mph (0–96 km/h) time of about 5.8 seconds for some variants.
Regarding fuel economy, figures vary depending on the version, but Audi mentions around 9.9 L/100 km (≈ 23.8 mpg) combined for the Canadian mild-hybrid versions. The Q5 also showcases strong technology features: digital dashboard (Digital Stage), large MMI screen, advanced connectivity, and increased modularity (sliding seats, flexible configurations).
Thus, the Q5 focuses heavily on Audi’s premium DNA, connectivity, and interior refinement.
Point-by-Point Comparison — Why the RDX Stands Out
Driving Dynamics and Agility in Montreal Conditions
In Montreal’s urban driving context, road conditions (potholes, uneven pavement, varying surfaces) require a vehicle that is agile, stable, and confidence-inspiring. The RDX’s SH-AWD system actively distributes torque, giving better control in cornering or slippery situations. This provides a real advantage over a more “standard” all-wheel-drive system like the one in the Q5.
In addition, the RDX is well tuned to deliver power at low RPM, which is an asset in Montreal’s urban traffic. Reviews consider the RDX’s acceleration and engine response to be lively. The Q5 is also strong, but the RDX has a slight edge in driving feel, providing a more dynamic sensation.
Comfort, Quietness, and Interior Space
The RDX interior is designed to balance space and comfort. Rear passengers have enough room for two adults to travel comfortably, even on longer trips. The cargo space is also competitive for the segment.
The Q5 emphasizes refinement — sound insulation, high-end materials, comfort features — but the RDX holds its own. Moreover, the RDX offers strong perceived value: often at a more accessible price (or with a better equipment level for the same budget), the RDX can offer more standard features.
In Montreal, where commuting often involves long periods of traffic, this comfort becomes noticeable. And for customers in Quebec, where road environments (salt, cracks, winter conditions) severely test materials, the RDX’s build quality and robustness can be a decisive factor.
Technology and Safety — A Generous Offering
Acura has equipped the RDX well in terms of technology and safety. The vehicle includes multiple driver-assistance systems such as collision mitigation, alerts, lane-keeping assistance, and more. Everything is well integrated without overwhelming the user. The infotainment system is smooth, compatible with Apple CarPlay / Android Auto, and intuitive enough for daily use.
Audi, on the other hand, is known for sophisticated tech interfaces — the new Q5 offers the Digital Stage system, a large central screen, and an immersive digital cockpit. However, this sophistication can be a double-edged sword: very complex systems can sometimes tire or distract the user, especially during daily Montreal commutes.
One advantage of the RDX is that it offers “just the right amount”: advanced technology without unnecessary complexity, ideal for users who want tech but also simplicity.
Maintenance, Resale Value, and Ease of Ownership
For a buyer in Quebec, several practical elements come into play: maintenance costs, parts availability, durability reputation, warranties, dealership network, etc. Acura has a strong presence in Quebec, including service centers in the Greater Montreal area. This can make repairs or regular maintenance easier for Montreal owners.
Resale value is an important criterion in the luxury segment: the RDX enjoys a solid reliability reputation (inherited from Honda/Acura). Total cost of ownership (insurance, maintenance, fuel) often leans in favor of the RDX in Canadian evaluations.
Audi also has a strong premium image, but maintenance costs (parts, specialized labor) can be higher, which can be a disadvantage over time, especially for budget-conscious owners in Quebec.
Real-World Use in Quebec — How It Plays Out Daily
Winter Use, Snow, and Ice
In Montreal, winter brings major challenges — snow, ice, salt on the roads. The RDX’s SH-AWD system and its torque-vectoring capability allow better traction distribution, helping the vehicle recover from slippery situations. In other words, the RDX manages loss of grip more effectively. The Q5’s quattro system is competent but more “passive” in operation (though still effective) — in the worst scenarios, the RDX may provide more leeway.
Urban Traffic, Parking, and Everyday Use
For those who drive around the Montreal area, dimensions, maneuverability, visibility, and ease of parking matter. The RDX is compact enough for city use while offering good rear visibility, useful for navigating narrow streets or tight parking spaces.
Moreover, the simplicity and robustness of the RDX’s systems can offer better reliability in demanding conditions, compared to more complex systems that may experience issues with sensors or electronics in extreme weather.
Range, Fuel Economy, and Inter-Regional Trips
For users who leave Montreal for getaways in the Eastern Townships, Mauricie, or elsewhere in Quebec, fuel economy and range matter. With a reasonable combined consumption (≈ 23 mpg equivalent), the RDX offers good range. The Q5, with its more powerful engine and mild-hybrid tech, offers similar fuel economy on some versions — but real-world differences depend on driving style.
Practical Advice for Buyers
-
Test drive in all conditions
During your test drive in Montreal, try the RDX in both wet and dry conditions, and on less-than-perfect roads, to experience SH-AWD behavior. Compare this with the Q5 in similar situations.
-
Compare trims and equipment
The RDX offers several trims (A-Spec, Advance, etc.). Check which features come standard (sunroof, leather, safety systems). A well-equipped RDX may surpass a base Q5.
-
Consider total cost of ownership
Think about insurance, maintenance, fuel consumption, and replacement parts. Over the years, the RDX often comes out ahead, especially in Quebec where climate conditions heavily stress the vehicle.
-
Warranties and service network
Verify Acura’s warranties in Quebec, as well as parts and service coverage in the Montreal area, and compare them to Audi’s. Having a certified service center nearby is a real advantage.
-
Plan for winter use
Choose quality winter tires and make sure the AWD system (SH-AWD for the RDX) is well maintained. In winter, this makes a noticeable difference in snowy or icy starts.
In short, the 2025 RDX combines agility, comfort, and reliability in a well-balanced package perfectly suited to Quebec. For Montreal drivers looking for a luxury SUV without compromise, it is often the most logical choice.
FAQ
1. What is the fuel economy of the 2025 Acura RDX compared to the Audi Q5?
The RDX achieves around 23 mpg combined (21 mpg city / 27 mpg highway) based on U.S. standards. The Q5, depending on the version, sits around 9.9 L/100 km (≈ 23.8 mpg combined) for some Canadian mild-hybrid versions. These figures vary depending on driving style and road conditions.
2. Does the RDX handle Quebec winters well?
Yes. The RDX’s SH-AWD system offers better traction distribution and helps in slippery conditions. Combined with quality winter tires, it is very effective in Montreal and across Quebec.
3. Which vehicle offers better value and equipment?
Often, the RDX offers more standard equipment for a similar price compared to a more basic Q5. That said, the Q5 carries strong brand prestige and premium finish, which can justify the difference.
4. How do maintenance costs compare?
Audi’s maintenance costs tend to be higher, especially for luxury or specialized components. Acura benefits from Honda/Acura’s reliability reputation and a well-established service network, which can make long-term ownership more economical.
5. Does the RDX hold its resale value well?
Yes, the RDX has a strong reputation and — thanks to its reliability, reasonable ownership costs, and Acura’s strong network in Quebec — it tends to retain good resale value. However, final resale depends on maintenance, mileage, and overall condition.
